Unethical behaviour on the part of the financial services industry in recent years has been a considerably destructive force. This behaviour goes well beyond the types of crises that triggered big bank bailouts. It also extends to practices within other sectors. For example, in Australia, multiple issues—including delays in processing and rejections of claims—have led many to call for a public inquiry into conduct in the sector and raised questions around whether culture should be regulated.

Unethical behaviour in the financial services industry has not only had a huge, negative global financial impact; it’s also been very costly in terms of reputation and brand—which does not bode well for the future of financial services as a whole. As I shared in the Employing a New Generation blog series, Millennials’ are increasingly unwilling to work in banking, insurance, and capital markets. They want to work for ethical organisations and are also distrustful of the financial services industry in general—being very wary when it comes to selecting financial partners. The result? Financial services firms are increasingly challenged to attract Millennials both as employees and as clients. This situation also opens opportunities for financial services disruptors.

How ethical failure is impacting the banking sector

Recently, Accenture (in partnership with Principia Advisory) spent several months conferring with bankers, academic experts, and industry observers to understand the impacts of this crisis, what’s behind it, and what to do about it.

Here are a few highlights from what they discovered:

  • Record-breaking fines among ten leading banks estimated at more than $250 billion over a five-year period, representing the destruction of more than 40% of “pre-loss” earnings
  • Significant erosion of brand equity due to public perception and distrust, along with increased public and regulatory scrutiny
  • Ongoing misguided and misdirected attempts to solve the ethics problem

While these discoveries might paint a grim picture, they also represent an opportunity. Consider this: a mere 10% reduction in regulatory fines could yield an additional $5 million in increased annual earnings for the banking industry. Trust destroyed is trust that can be rebuilt through trustworthy actions. However, the third bullet point seems to be the stumbling block.

It’s about culture, not rules and rewards

All too often firms have taken a knee-jerk approach to solving ethical issues by introducing more rules and rewarding external behaviours. The problem is, in financial services there’s no lack of rules and regulations. However, the unspoken rules often carry more weight, and those unspoken rules can conflict with ethical behaviour. Additionally, financial services firms often incentivise employees the wrong way for the wrong things.

For example, if an unethical practice offers a much more lucrative reward (such as big bonuses and opportunities for advancement) as compared to a lesser or token reward for obeying a rule, employees will continually be challenged to make the right choice—especially if choosing the former is the norm. If the ethical crisis in financial services is to be successfully resolved, intrinsic rewards—such as the satisfaction that comes from properly serving customers—must take top priority.

Lastly, industries that are built on a quick return and accustomed to operating at the whim of the markets tend to favor short term action over long term benefits. It’s no wonder attempts to solve the ethical crisis often don’t stick.

What’s required to evolve financial services into a truly ethical industry is a change in attitude and behaviour—a cultural transformation based on intrinsic ethical values and employees who are empowered to make the right decisions, every time.

In my next post, I’ll share more about how cultural transformation creates a strategic opportunity for financial services, and what to watch out for along the way as you work to embed ethics into your company’s culture.

To learn more about creating an ethical culture, please see:

Beyond compliance

The ethics and conduct risk challenge for US banks

One response:

  1. I totally agree. No rules and regulations can help if people do not have a conscience and compassion anymore. “Compliance” cannot replace decency, it can only enhance it.

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *